American vs Chinese Mahjong: The Differences
Prefer to watch? This short lesson covers the essentials. All video lessons
If you learned Mahjong from a grandmother in Hong Kong and then sat down at a table in Florida, you would recognise the tiles and almost nothing else. The two games share an ancestor and have been growing apart for a century.
At a glance
| American | Chinese (most styles) | |
|---|---|---|
| Tiles | 152, including 8 Jokers | 144, no Jokers |
| Winning hands | Only the hands printed on a card | Four sets and a pair, in many combinations |
| Sequences | Not used as sets | Chows (runs of three) are central |
| Before play | The Charleston: three or six passes | None |
| Flowers | Part of the hands on the card | Bonus tiles, set aside and replaced |
| Calling | For three or more of a kind, or to win | For pungs, kongs, and chows from the player before you |
| Scoring | A fixed value per hand | Points or doubles built up from the hand’s features |
The card
This is the biggest difference. In Chinese styles, any hand of the right shape can win, and skill lies in building it efficiently and scoring it well. In the American game the only winning hands are the ones on a card, and many of them are patterns you would never see elsewhere: kongs of Flowers, the year in tiles, pairs of every wind. Reading the card and choosing a line is half the game. See how to read a card.
Jokers
Eight wild tiles change everything. They make big groups such as kongs and quints achievable, and they create a little market at the table: a Joker lying in an exposure can be taken by anyone holding the real tile. Chinese styles have nothing like it. See the Joker rules.
The Charleston
American players exchange at least nine tiles before a single discard. It makes the opening less about luck and more about judgement, and it is the part newcomers from other styles find strangest. See the Charleston.
No chows
In Chinese Mahjong a run of 3-4-5 in one suit is a set. In American Mahjong it is not. “Consecutive run” hands on the card are made of pungs and kongs of neighbouring numbers, not of sequences.
Which is easier to learn?
Chinese Mahjong has a simpler goal and a harder scoring system. American Mahjong has a harder goal, since you must learn to read the card, and scoring you can explain in a minute. Most people find whichever they learned second to be the confusing one.
Which one is this site?
American-style, throughout: 152 tiles, Jokers, the Charleston and a card of hands. It is not the tile-matching solitaire game either, which borrows the tiles and nothing else.