Play free

Charleston Strategy: What to Pass and What to Keep

What to pass and what to keep 1:08

Prefer to watch? This short lesson covers the essentials. All video lessons

You will give away at least nine tiles before the first discard. Players who do that thoughtfully start the game two or three tiles closer to Mahjong than players who do not. This is where most hands are won.

If you need the order of the passes first, read the Charleston, step by step.

Start by reading your hand

Sort your tiles and ask four questions.

  1. How many Jokers? Two or more opens up kongs and quints. None makes pairs matter even more.
  2. Any pairs? Pairs are precious, because Jokers cannot make them. Find hands that use the pairs you already hold.
  3. What do I have most of? Evens, odds, a run of neighbours, one suit, winds, 3-6-9.
  4. What clearly does not belong? Those are your first three tiles.
Two pairs of evens and a Joker. The 3 and 7 Crak, the winds and the Red Dragon are the strays

The first pass: the obvious strays

Pass the tiles that fit nothing: lone winds, a dragon that matches none of your suits, the odd number in a rack of evens. Do not agonise. There are two more passes.

The second pass: narrow to a section

You have three new tiles. Look again. Usually one family has grown and another has not. Let the weaker one go. By the end of this pass you want to be choosing between two or three hands in the same section of the card.

The third pass: protect what you have

By now you may not have three tiles you are happy to lose. That is what the blind pass is for: pass along some of the tiles coming to you, unseen, and keep your own. Use it when your hand has come together. Do not use it by habit, because the tiles you forward might have been exactly what you needed.

Should you agree to a second Charleston?

  • Say yes if you are still deciding between sections, or you hold several tiles that fit nothing.
  • Say no if you are within about five tiles of a hand and would have to break something up to find three to pass.

Any one player can stop it, and nobody is owed an explanation.

The courtesy pass

Ask for as many tiles as you have true strays, up to three. If you have none, ask for none. Offering three tiles you would rather keep just to be agreeable is the commonest way to weaken a good hand.

What good players avoid

  • Passing pairs. Two of the same tile to the same player is a gift.
  • Passing a sequence. A 4, 5 and 6 of one suit together tells your neighbour exactly which hand to play.
  • Passing Flowers early. Many hands use them. Wait until you know yours does not.
  • Hoarding winds “just in case.” Unless you are playing winds, they are the cheapest tiles to let go.
  • Falling in love. If the tiles you receive point somewhere else, go there.

Notice what comes back

If the player on your left keeps passing you Craks, she is probably not playing Craks. That is information about what will be safe to discard later, and about what she will not be throwing you.

Practise it deliberately

In a practice game here, a small marker appears over the three tiles that serve your closest hands least. Before you look at it, choose your own three. Then compare. Ten Charlestons like that will teach you more than any list.